With automakers falling over themselves to launch their newest and shiniest electric vehicles, with NASA-like battery technology and ever-increasing range, it’s easy to dismiss plain old hybrid expertise — the type successfully pioneered by Toyota with its Prius line of cars some 20 years ago — as a simple way to achieve decent fuel economy and lower emissions. Admittedly, hybrids are a mere stepping stone to the totally green transportation envisioned by 2050, but they’re also a lot more affordable, less complicated and therefore more palatable to a greater percentage of consumers.
However, hybrid powertrains still aren’t an overly popular sell, especially in cars. Toyota Canada in particular notes that 16 per cent of its Camry sales are the Hybrid, Honda Canada stating less than 10 per cent of its Accord sales are hybrid. That said, it’s heartening to see some manufacturers refusing to give up, including adding the technology to their lines of popular crossovers.
Still, for this Tale of the Tape, we’ll look at the former — two mid-sized, highly respected sedans from two highly respected automakers. While not brand new, both the 2021 Accord and Camry hybrids receive mid-cycle refreshes, with minor cosmetic tweaks along with updates to various driving and safety features.
Models
On-sale at Honda dealerships as of December, the 2021 Accord Hybrid is available in two trim levels. The base Hybrid starts at $35,805, and the fancier Hybrid Touring coming in at $42,505.
Toyota counters with no less than four trim levels for the Camry Hybrid, starting with the LE at $30,790, some $760 less than the 2020 model. It then continues with the “sportier” SE ($34,050), the sport/luxe XSE ($37,390), and the top-line XLE ($39,690).
Styling
For the 2021 model year, all Accords boast a wider, restyled grille along with improved integration of the Honda Sensing system’s radar unit. Flanking the new grille are new, full LED headlights with longer and wider down-the-road illumination. Also new are smaller openings for the fog lights. Visually, the Accord Hybrid adds its own touches, mostly unique badging all around. This year, the Hybrid Touring features 19-inch wheels for a more upscale and sporty appearance.
The 2021 Camry, whether gas- or hybrid-powered, see very subtle styling tweaks. The front fascia for the “comfort-oriented” LE and XLE has a more defined lower intake area compared with SE and XSE. In addition to the different front fascia, the new XSE trim comes with gloss black 19-inch wheels.
Powertrain
There are more similarities than differences between Honda and Toyota’s approaches to their hybrid setups, the size of their respective four-cylinder gas engines and the terminology used being the biggest distinctions.
Honda notes updates to its “two-motor” hybrid system, which consists of a 2.0-litre, DOHC, i-VTEC Atkinson-cycle engine and an AC synchronous permanent-magnet electric motor. The company says these changes result in “a more direct and immediate throttle response with a more natural acceleration feeling as engine revs climb in concert with throttle input.” Peak total system output is 212 horsepower, and with a peak torque delivery of 232 pound-feet of torque right off idle, Honda claims the Accord Hybrid provides the most power and torque in its class. Power is fed to the front wheels via a continuously variable transmission.
The hybrid powertrain control system switches between EV Drive, Hybrid Drive and Engine Drive for maximum efficiency with no input from the driver. Honda notes that drivers can further maximize fuel efficiency or power by selecting between Sport, EV, and Econ modes using the three buttons behind the push-button gear selector.
For the tech geeks and environmentalists out there, Honda’s says its hybrid system uses a propulsion motor and a generator/starter motor built with a patented design made with magnets using no heavy rare-earth metals. This, according to Honda, reduces magnet cost and weight while also reducing reliance on rare-earth metals, helping avoid the often-negative environmental impact of mining them.
Meanwhile, the Camry Hybrid’s powertrain centres around Toyota’s Hybrid Synergy Drive, “the most popular and proven advanced power train on the planet,” the company boasts. This system combines a 2.5L DOHC Atkinson-cycle four-cylinder producing 176 hp and 163 lb-ft of torque. Paired with the 118-hp electric motor, the total hybrid system net output is 208 hp. It’s mated to an electronically controlled CVT that mimics a six-speed automatic transmission via paddle shifters (on SE and XSE trims) or with the console-mounted shift lever. Along with the traditional Normal, Eco, and EV drive system modes, a Sport mode allows for an increase in power from the hybrid system for improved acceleration.
One interesting feature is Auto Glide Control (AGC), which helps to improve fuel efficiency by calculating “efficient coasting logic.” AGC can be activated only when the Camry is being operated in Eco, limiting the loss of vehicle speed through engine braking and acting more like a neutral gear to allow longer coasting.
Not that blinding acceleration is expected, but both cars can get out of their own way when called upon: Motor Trend recorded a 7.4-second run from zero to 60-mph (97 km/h) time for the Camry Hybrid, which tips the scale between 1,578 and 1,624 kilograms depending on the trim level. The Accord Hybrid, thanks to its greater net horsepower output and trimmer weight (1,534 to 1,567 kg), is quicker, at 6.7 seconds.
Fuel efficiency
Well, this is really what it’s all about, isn’t it? Foregoing fanfare, the official results from NRCan are thus: the Camry Hybrid is rated 4.9 L /100 kilometres in the city and 4.8 on the highway. The base Accord Hybrid is rated at 5.0 L/100 km for both city and highway, the Touring version a little thirstier at 5.3 and 5.7 in the city and highway, respectively.
Dimensions
It’s a matter of mere millimetres difference between these two four-door, mid-sized sedans in terms of major dimensions — length, height and wheelbase, with the Accord Hybrid just a teensy bit larger overall. For instance, the Honda has a length of 4,882 mm, versus 4,879 mm for the Toyota. For those who prefer the Imperial system, it’s the difference of one-tenth of an inch.
However, in terms of interior room, there’s slightly more stretch-out space in the Accord, more so for rear-seat passengers who get a couple of extra inches of legroom. The passenger volume of the base Accord Hybrid is 2,990 litres, and 2,908 litres for the Touring. The Camry Hybrid has a passenger volume of 2,803 litres.
The same applies to cargo capacity, the Honda offering a more commodious 473 litres versus the Toyota’s 445 litres. In order to retain reasonable trunk room, both the Accord and Camry use lithium-ion battery packs installed beneath the rear seat.
Safety
For the 2021 model year, all Accords are equipped with a blind-spot monitoring system and receive a new rear seat reminder and a rear seatbelt reminder as standard equipment. The rear seat reminder chimes when the car is turned off, with a notification reminding drivers to check the rear seating area when exiting the car for children, pets, etc. The rear seatbelt reminder uses a warning to let drivers know if rear seat passengers have not fastened their seatbelts.
Touring trims now feature a new front and rear braking system called Low Speed Braking Control. Using sonar-based parking sensors, the new system can sense solid objects at low speeds, such as in parking situations, and warn the driver or apply the brakes to help avoid or lessen the effects of a collision.
Honda Sensing receives updates to the adaptive cruise control (ACC) and lane keeping assist systems (LKAS). For 2021, Honda says the adaptive cruise control system now has smoother braking when following another vehicle, while the lane-keep assist offers more effective and natural lane centering.
Toyota’s impressively long list of standard safety systems now includes Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+, the latest iteration of the automaker’s bundle of active safety technologies. The enhanced package now features intersection support, designed to detect an oncoming vehicle or pedestrian when performing a left-hand turn and provide audio/visual alerts or automatic braking depending on the conditions. In addition, TSS 2.5+ offers emergency steering assist, lane-departure alert with steering assist and road edge detection, automatic high beams, pre-collision system with pedestrian and bicycle detection, lane tracing assist, and dynamic radar cruise control.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration in the U.S. has given both sedans a five-star safety rating.
Verdict
It would be hard to find two more similar vehicles that are virtually identical in exterior dimensions, and close enough in interior dimensions, powertrain outputs, and pricing. The Accord is a bit quicker, the Camry a little more fuel efficient. Though neither could be called luxury sedans, their respective topline trims offer an impressive list of features.
Consumer Reports recommends both cars, but lauds the Camry as “one of the best models among midsized sedans thanks to a comfortable ride, quiet cabin, good fuel economy, and easy-to-use controls.”
All things considered, one of the only reasons to give the nod to the Camry Hybrid is that it offers four specific trim levels to the Accord Hybrid’s two, with price points lower at both the base and top end.
January 05, 2021 at 05:18AM
https://ift.tt/3os7Hzf
Tale of the Tape: 2021 Toyota Camry Hybrid vs. 2021 Honda Accord Hybrid - Driving
https://ift.tt/38hkzRl
Honda
No comments:
Post a Comment